Covering bad bosses, workplace discrimination, sexual harassment, and hostile work environment complaints
Saturday October 25th 2014

Insider

Archives

3 Dallas Fire-Rescue sexual harassment lawsuits have cost the city $1.4 million in legal fees

Chief Eddie Burns accused of sexual harassment

Chief Eddie Burns

According to The Dallas Morning News, the “city of Dallas has spent nearly $1.4 million in legal fees defending itself in three sexual harassment lawsuits filed by four women against Dallas Fire-Rescue.”

Two of the lawsuits were settled recently for over $250,000.  In June, the city agreed to pay employee Helen Watts $30,000 to settle the sexual harassment lawsuit that she had filed.  In October, the city agreed to pay former employee Cheryl Hill and current employee Sherrie Lopez a total of $225,000 to end their case. 

Hill alleges that she found semen in her coffee mug and smeared on a photograph of her daughter in her office.  Lopez claims that she would often find personal items destroyed and once discovered someone had urinated on the rug near her bed.

The third lawsuit, filed by former employee Leanne Siri-Edwards, has not been resolved yet.  Siri-Edwards, who was once the highest-ranking woman at Dallas Fire-Rescue, was fired in August 2009 – several months after she filed a sexual harassment and hostile work environment against the city. 

Hill and Lopez allege that when they complained to their supervisors about the hostile incidents, their complaints were mostly ignored and they often suffered retaliation.

The following are excerpts from the Hill-Lopez complaint, which was filed on Sept 8, 2010 (the entire complaint can be accessed here):

Chief Eddie Burns publicly [told] the DFR’s highest-ranking female employee, “the problem is you’re a woman” and that she should be seen but not heard in meetings.

Chief Burns [made] sexual advances to as many as three female subordinates.

Chief Burns promoted a male DFR employee who was known to consistently sexually harass female employees, thus furthering an environment that accepts and approves of harassment of members of the Class;

Additionally, it has been reported that Chief Burns himself, on at least three separate occasions, met with perpetrators of workplace assault, battery, discrimination and harassment and counseled them on how to refute and avoid the charges against them.

In the interim between reporting of the Berkshire Report to the Dallas City Council and hiring of the EEO Officer and Assistant Chief of Professional Responsibility, Chief Burns asked DFR’s Executive Officer, Leanne Siri, to develop an anti-racism and sexual harassment/discrimination program. In developing the program, Siri met with James Adams, a black male who led DFR’s Internal Affairs Department (“IAD”) at the time of the Berkshire Report, to discuss the existing processes and training and ways in which they could and should be improved. She was dismayed to see an inappropriate CD cover depicting a nude woman wrapped in a fire hose displayed in Adams’ office.

Approximately three weeks later, on April 1, 2008, Hill arrived at work, unlocked her office door, turned on her light, put up her purse, sat down at her desk and reached for her coffee cup, which she had cleaned the day before. As she looked down into her cup, she noticed a fluid in the bottom that appeared to be seminal fluid. She then noticed the substance was also smeared on a photo of her daughter.

On July 23, 2008, nearly four months after the date of Hill’s report, DFR’s Internal Affairs interviewed Rolando Banda (the prior occupant of the office and one of the few people who Hill originally reported had keys to her office) regarding the incident. During questioning, Banda admitted he was the perpetrator. Despite DFR’s supposed “no tolerance” policy, Banda was placed on paid administrative leave until October 2, 2008, when he retired from DFR.

Lopez received a disturbing call from Terry Roberts, the Lieutenant in charge of her station.  Lt. Roberts was angry at Lopez for investigating the swing issue, and berated Lopez, yelling, “I don’t like you, I don’t trust you, and I want you out of here!” and “You bring this shift down!”  Lopez feared for her personal safety and her job after the call.

In the Spring of 2007, after almost nine years at Station 9, Lopez had given up.  She sought transfer to work at a desk job at City Hall.

In September 2007, Lopez filled out a witness statement with DFR’s Internal Affairs Department complaining of the harassment as well as the TAP issue.

On or about October 4, 2007, Lopez received another disturbing phone call from Lieutenant Roberts.  Roberts accused Lopez of lying about him and being after his job.  Lopez was again in fear for her safety.

On the same day, Lopez reported the call to Captain Frank Drahos, who was performing the Internal Affairs investigation.  Drahos asked Lopez to report to Internal Affairs and berated Lopez.

While at City Hall, Lopez continued to face discrimination and harassment.  DFR employees, including high-ranking officers, would make comments about Lopez or her female supervisor as they pased her in the hallways or on the street.  For example, on one occasion, Chief Mike Jones referred to Lopez as “Siri’s bitch,” in front of Lopez.  Lopez reported the incident to Chief Tom Tanksley.  Upon information and belief, no action was taken.

Additionally, Lopez continued to find it difficult to perform her job responsibilities…she would often find DFR Chiefs were hesitant, or even outright resistant, to provide her with information she requested.

On one occasion, Lopez was assigned by her female supervisor (Leanne Siri) to go to the Academy and gather information about the rookie class.  However, when Lopez attempted to perform her job, Chief Max Kirk said, “Don’t give her anything, she works for the enemy.”

——————–

Got a tip about a bad boss that eBossWatch should feature?  Do you want to expose your toxic boss?  Let us know!  Send us an email at tips@ebosswatch.com

Rate your boss at eBossWatch

3 Dallas Fire-Rescue sexual harassment lawsuits have cost the city $1.4 million in legal fees
1 vote, 5.00 avg. rating (98% score)
  • http://www.stevengravesinsurance.com Insurance Agent Dallas

    So glad these women are standing up for their rights. Keep up the good work.

  • John

    It should be notated that most of all the issues you have read about have not happened out in the stations where the firefighters work. It should also be notated the DFR employees are not necessarily firefighters. An example of a DFR employee are the mechanics who work on our vehicles and clothing and supply employees who help distribute our uniforms. Some of the issues you are reading about concern these types of employees and not firefighters directly.

  • Kalola R

    Yes Eddie Burns is indeed a real “peach” of a guy. But his tenure and continued employment begs the question, who is worse, him or the person who hired him and keeps him in his position? Who is his boss you may ask? Well her name is Mary Suhm Dallas city manager who has the power to fire him at any time. Why would any boss, especially a woman, keep him in their employ? Maybe she should really head this list, and he must have some powerful dirt on her, or she must be a prize idiot to not fire him. From what I know and have seen of her it could be either. Lastly if she would keep this moron and his cronies employed, and with other things she has been party to, I have to also wonder how Mary Suhm keeps her job too?

  • concerned dallas resident

    As a fellow dallas resident, who often attends city meetings, I am appalled to read this. I can not believe all this has been going on and no disciplinary action has been taken. If this was in the private sector……… heads would roll!
    I mean, COME ON!!!! This man is the Fire Chief of one of the largest cities in America! I often hear how moral is very low in the fire dept……….. now I see why!
    I am disgusted that my city manager would tolerate this. I am embarrassed! Dallas is one of the best cities in america….. a Top Fortune 500 city. How can we let this happen? How can the city pay “taxpayer money” in $1.5M of legal fees? This is OUTRAGEOUS!
    You can guarantee, that I as a dallas resident, want answers. MY final word is this: Chief Burns should be fired immediately! And Mary Suhm should be held accountable as well.

  • Duncan

    This article has the makings of a witch hunt for a fall guy. Furthermore, this is only one side of the story. The article read as if these issues just happened within the past couple of years when actually it appears that these issues are from some years ago.

    I believe that Chief Burns, is one of the most concerned executive officers’ that believes in policy and respect for women in the workforce. Chief Burns has always shown respect towards women firefighters. At least the Lopez issues seemed ongoing almost a decade before Chief Burns became Chief to DFR. In the response to Mr. John, who claims that none of the issues were at the fire stations where the firefighters stay, apparently he didn’t read where Lopez was assigned to station #9.

    I believed Chief Burns acted upon information he was informed about which is why he probably hired Ms. Siri. It appears, that Ms. Siri had her own planning for harassment complaints and in developing an anti-racial and harassment policy for the department.

  • Kathleen

    it seems to me that all of the these bad bosses are on here for sexual harrasment. so why do men in power seem to think that women below them are theirs to do with as they will. Its obviously because the world in which they grew up has shown them it is ok to do. i am only 18 years old and i dont want to have to go to my first job in 4 years and immediatly have to ward of men who will not give up, or who would try to coerce me. These women are somebodies daughters and mothers and wifes, they could be yours. the only way harrasment will end is when men are taught that women’s brains are equal to theirs even if our strength is not.

  • Rufus

    Congratulations to Burns for making the “America’s Worst Bosses” list! I’m guessing that if the city tried to get rid of him, there would be a racial discrimination suit filed in record time, even though his dismissal might very well be fully justifiable. Just a hunch.

  • Duncan

    If these accusations were true, Chief Burns would have been fired already and he would not be on America’s Worst eboss watch list. However, these accusations need to form some kind of alliance to provoke a fabricated truth to the articles. Yeah!, This is where the groupies of “I really don’t know” get on the band wagon.

  • Dallas

    This idiot just resigned. Hmm…wonder why?

    All the Dallas city officials need to get the axe. They’re all corrupted…especially that racist John Wiley Price.

  • joe bleach

    This article is not the conclusion of any formal investigation,,instead its all based on hearsay from disgruntled employee’s that probably feel they were passed over for promotion.

  • John

    I am a male that works at a fire station. According to the trespasses against these women it appears that I am due some $11,000,000. LOL.
    As a firefighter, your entire existence at the station is one of barbs, comments, jokes, roughhousing and belittling the other guy.